Conceptualizing credibility of testimony

Bertil Rolf

[Back to paper list] [Start page] [Alphabetical index]

Keywords: Testimony, Credibility, Reliability, Evidence, Epistemics, Hume, Goldman, Shapin.

: Two questions are focused below: (1) What is the character of credibility, i.e. justified belief based on testimony? and (2) What epistemological framework is needed to study the credibility of testimony? The questions are interdependent. A characterization of credibility is pointless unless we are clear about what we want to conceptualize and why. My aim in this article - "paper" is hardly the right word for it - is to steer between a rationalizing, epistemological Scylla that neglects all characteristic features of testimony and a relativizing, descriptive Charybdis that makes studies of testimony a subspecies of psychology or sociology. The standpoint advocated is related to Alvin Goldman's epistemics.

here to obtain the paper in PDF format.

Bertil Rolf
Professor of Philosophy
University of Karlskrona/Ronneby

Spinning Ideas, Electronic Essays
Dedicated to Peter Gärdenfors on His Fiftieth Birthday