Hans Rott at LMPS 1987

Two Dogmas of Belief Revison

Hans Rott

[Back to paper list] [Start page] [Alphabetical index]

Keywords: Belief revision, Conservatism, Informational economy, Minimal change, Minimum mutilation, Theory change, Truth, Two Dogmas, Alchourron, Gardenfors, Makinson, Quine.

: The paper attacks the widely held view that belief revision theories, as they have been studied in the past two decades, are founded on the Principle of Informational Economy. The principle comes in two versions. According to the first, an agent should, when accepting a new piece of information, aim at a minimal change of his previously held beliefs. If there are different ways to effect the belief change, then the agent should, according to the second version, give up those beliefs that are least entrenched. Although widely proclaimed by belief revision theorists, I argue that both versions of the principle are dogmas that are not (and perhaps should not be) adhered to. I substantiate this claim with two simple mathematical observations, and I defend it against four possible objections that involve contractions, reconstructions, dispositions, and truths.

here to obtain the paper in PDF format.

Hans Rott,
Institute for Philosophy, University of Regensburg, Germany

Spinning Ideas, Electronic Essays
Dedicated to Peter Gärdenfors on His Fiftieth Birthday